At college, we just had an ongoing debate about the new Islamic cultural center that is being built 3 blocks away from the World Trade Center site. A lot of people in the classroom seemed against it, but I, along with around 4 or 5 other students, including the teacher, were all for it.
If I don't write about this, it will bother me the rest of the day, so I'm just going to let it all out.
People who are against the building of the culture center are just purely racist, stereotypical, ignorant, and "un-american" (yes, I'm using that word). They are because of the following reasons.
The people against building the center are stating that just the presence of these people's culture is "offensive." Is it not racist to say that a certain people's culture is offending? I think it is. You can say you're not racist or stereotypical all day, but that doesn't make it true. There is a term called "subconsciously racist" where people believe that their views aren't racist when in reality they are racist. Anyone who says that they are against it's building, but claim their not racist or stereotypical is unaware of the underlining racism in their claims.
America is a country of millions of different cultures and races from all over the world. We should show the world that despite that we were attack by extremists, who have a SLIGHT relation to Islamic people (but are two completely different groups of people), we still do not discriminate, we still encourage diversity, and we do not have a double standard when it comes to other cultures. People who are against the building of the cultural center are "un-american," (even though I hate the ring of that term) because they are against what America is in the first place. A place of diversity. If you're against the tolerance of other races, cultures, and religions, than you are against the very foundation of what America was founded.
The cultural center is not even in the same vicinity as the WTC site. It is 3 blocks away from the site, and NYC blocks are very very large compared to other cities. So, just the fact that these people are making a big deal out of this, when it's not even significantly close to the site in the first place, also shows the underlining racism. They are so keen, so quick, to impose their prejudices on this group of people, that they jump into a such a small event as a reason to state their claims. They're using this insignificant event as justification for their prejudices.
I often use a different analogy to compare to this situation. If a town were to build a German cultural center 3 blocks away from a Jewish synagogue, of course there would be no problem with that. Why? Well, Germans are white, most people know that not all Germans are Nazis (in fact, only around 10% of German people during the Nazi regime were in fact Nazis or belonged to the Nazi party, and most of that percent were brain washed into believe in it) and it happened during World War 2.
Muslims are NOT extremists. They did not support the terrorist's attack, they are not terrorists themselves, and they ALSO lost people during the 9/11 attacks. They are victims just like any other America who was affect by the attacks. Yes, there might some people in America who do agree with the terrorist attacks, but we shouldn't stop the building of it just because of that small amount of people. Why address their hatred? You fight fire with water, not with fire, because it just fuels the flame.
A lot of these claims against the building of the center are also based on assumptions. Assuming that Muslims who are extremists will see that center as a "victory symbol" is just an assumption. And even if they do, so what? Who cares what they think? We're the ones who know the truth and what the center is really about and what it's not about. What others think makes no importance. Anyone can think anything is symbol of something when it's really not. People care too much on what those people will think, or what that group will think if we do this and so and so fourth. No one knows that the truth of what something really is will be what really matters.
Furthermore, if it were a bunch of extreme Christians or Catholics that were behind the attacks on 9/11, would there still be controversy if they wanted to build a Church in the same area? Of course not. They even wanted to put a cross on the WTC site!
Why are you blaming an entire religion for the work of a handful of radical Muslims? If you're letting your views of those radicals over take your view of an entire religion, why not do it with Christianity as well? So we'll take Christian radicals, like the congregation of the Westboro Baptist Church and make a generalization that all Christians feel the same ay as they do. Do you think all Christians hate gays? Do you think all Christians believe that all of the soldiers killed overseas deserve to have their funerals protested? I'm pretty sure you don't believe all Christians believe what the people of the Westboro Baptist Church do. So why would you believe all Muslims feel the same way as the handful of radicals that flew planes into the World Trade Centers.